Goodman claims that the Old Town charter allows a deputy to give a sheriff a ticket, but when they discover that the charter is a fake, they're led on a wild adventure to find the real charter and unravel the mysteries of Old Town's founder.
Somebody or something is kidnapping good guys all around town; when the sheriff discovers that he's not good enough to be kidnapped, he sets out to prove that he's the greatest guy in town.
When the sheriff realizes that an addiction to his momma's pudding is allowing her to control him, he decides to better his relationship with her by kicking his pudding habit.
An upset Mayor forbids Sheriff's friends from hanging around the station so that he can focus on stopping crime; to keep them around, Sheriff knights his friends, landing him in a predicament of medieval proportions.